Sweet Tooth Bites

By 05/11/2021March 7th, 20244 Comments

It’s nearly impossible to bite off more than you can chew with this ghoulishly fun appetizer. A simple horror ‘douvres of herbed goat cheese molded into teeth with a bloody mixture of sour cherry jam and honey on mini bite-sized toasts. It’s so simple to make that its hardly a recipe at all…assemble store bought items to make this quick and easy Halloween appetizer that’ll gross out your friends, all the while satisfying their sweet tooth. Enjoy!

Sweet Tooth Bites

Sink your teeth into these ghoulishly fun Halloween appetizers that come together in a flash, made with goat cheese, jam and mini toasts.
5 from 2 votes
Print Pin Rate
Course: Appetizer
Cuisine: Halloween Food
Keyword: bruschetta, cheese board, Halloween
Servings: 2 dozen


  • 4 oz. herbed goat cheese
  • 1 package mini toasts (I used Egalite Mini Toasts)
  • ½ cup sour cherry jam (substitute with raspberry or strawberry jam)
  • ½ cup honey


  • Spread goat cheese into tooth mold with a knife and then freeze for a minimum of one hour. Pop out frozen teeth from mold and place them in a plastic container and return to the freezer. Repeat spreading of the remaining goat cheese into the molds to make another batch of teeth and place in the freezer for another hour.
    (Note: These can be made ahead and kept frozen until ready to assemble)
  • Once teeth are frozen, mix jam and honey in a small bowl until combined and spread jam mixture onto toasts. Remove frozen teeth from the freezer and dip teeth roots into the honey jam mixture and place on toasts. Top with additional jam honey mixture if desired.
  • Allow the assembled sweet tooth bites to sit at room temperature for ~10 minutes before serving to allow the goat cheese to soften. Serve all by themselves or as an addition to a Halloween themed charcuterie board.


Teeth Mold from


Leave a Reply

Recipe Rating